|
1
|
|
|
2
|
- Virtually never should a quotation appear as a separate sentence in your
paper, unaccompanied by some introductory, or sometimes trailing,
phrase.
|
|
3
|
- Introduce a quotation by signaling that it is coming and perhaps by
indicating your purpose in using it.
- How?
|
|
4
|
- You may name the title of the source and the author in a signal phrase:
- In her book Contemporary
Feminist Thought, Eisenstein warns against a "false universalism
that addresses itself to all women."
|
|
5
|
- Or you may wish to name only the author:
- In a discussion of
Enlightenment political philosophy, Eisenstein asserts that while
"liberal theory contested the divine right of monarchs and
aristocrats to political rule," women questioned the
"divine" right of men to deny suffrage to half the population.1
|
|
6
|
- There are many graceful ways to
integrate a quotation into your text, but try to keep in mind that
quotations are confusing if they appear to
|
|
7
|
|
|
8
|
- In this poem it is creation, not a hypothetical creator, that is
supremely awesome. [argument sentence] The speaker asks, "What
immortal hand or eye / Dare frame thy fearful symmetry?" [data
sentence; orienter before quote]
|
|
9
|
- Gatsby is not to be regarded as a personal failure. [argument sentence]
"Gatsby turned out all right at the end" (176), according to
Nick. [data sentence; orienter after quote]
- "I know you blame me," Mrs. Compson tells Jason (47). [data
sentence; orienter after quote] Is she expressing her own sense of
guilt? [argument sentence]
|
|
10
|
- Vivian hates the knights for scorning her, and she dreams of achieving
glory by destroying Merlin's: "I have made his glory mine"
(390).
|
|
11
|
- Fitzgerald gives Nick a muted tribute to the hero: "Gatsby turned
out all right at the end" (176).
- Cassio represents not only a political but also a personal threat to
Iago: "He hath a daily beauty in his life / That makes me ugly . .
." (5.1.19-20).
|
|
12
|
- For Nick, who remarks that Gatsby "turned out all right"
(176), the hero deserves respect but perhaps does not inspire great
admiration.
- Satan's motion is many things; he "rides" through the air
(63), "rattles" (65), and later explodes, "wanders and
hovers" like a fire (293).
- © 2001
- The University of
Wisconsin-Madison Writing Center
- <writing@facstaff.wisc.edu>
|
|
13
|
- The goal of introducing direct quotations into your paper is
- to support the points you are trying to make.
- If the quotations are carefully introduced, the reader knows at all
times who is speaking,
- and the reader will not be jarred by awkward shifts in sentence style or
syntax.
|
|
14
|
- Thus, the test of good incorporation of quoted material into your text
is to
- read your text aloud, including the quoted material, neither pausing nor
making reference to quotation marks.
- The text should read as smoothly as though it were all in your own
words. Work the quotations into your own sentences. To do this, try the
following strategies.
|
|
15
|
- Use a variety of words or phrases to introduce the quoted material, not
only to prevent monotony, but also
- (1) to add to the authority, and
- (2) to indicate why you are quoting.
|
|
16
|
- Many terms may be used to introduce quoted material:
- asserts, believes, claims, comments, confirms, declares, defines,
describes, explains, indicates, makes clear, proposes, etc.
- However, these terms are not interchangeable. Make your choice based on
your meaning.
|
|
17
|
- Example: All of us know the grammar of our own language because, as
Robert C. Pooley writes, “Grammar is the structure: the observation of
what people do when they use English words in discourse. Grammar, as
here defined," he continues, "makes no choices, expresses no
preferences, takes no sides, creates no standards" (95).
|
|
18
|
- Maintain continuity between the direct quotation, the summary, the
paraphrase, and the comment that surrounds it. When direct quotations
are used effectively, they are usually
- introduced purposefully,
- set in an appropriate context through summary,
- adjusted to the syntax of the paper by paraphrase, and
- commented upon by the author of the paper.
|
|
19
|
- Example: Edward P. J. Corbett, one of America's most distinguished
rhetoricians, defines grammar clearly "as the study of how a
language 'works'--a study of how the structural system of a language
combines with a vocabulary to convey meaning" (111).
|
|
20
|
- In March, 1979, J. Thomas Underleider and David K. Wellisch reported in
the American Journal of Psychiatry that they had taken up the issue of
"coercive persuasion (brainwashing)" and
"deprogramming" in the religious cults because deprogramming
had raised "intriguing and disturbing questions for the medical,
and legal and mental health professions." They again cite the eight
elements of brainwashing, summarizing Lifton's earlier description.
- Deprogramming, according to Underleider and Wellisch, uses methods
ranging from "gentle rap" sessions to sleep deprivation and
sensory overload, with marathon-type encounters that feature shouting,
repetitious derogation of the cult, isolation of the person from his
associates . . . and, occasionally, use of physical force" (279). The
methods seem to be strikingly like brainwashing.
|
|
21
|
- Note that the author has introduced the quotation by establishing the
authority of Underleider and Wellisch.
- J. Thomas Underleider and David K. Wellisch reported in the American
Journal of Psychiatry
|
|
22
|
- Note that the author established the context by summarizing the reasons
they were studying the phenomenon called "brainwashing."
- because deprogramming had raised "intriguing and disturbing
questions for the medical, and legal and mental health
professions."
|
|
23
|
- Note that the author has adjusted the syntax of the quoted material to
the syntax of the paper by paraphrasing a few words just before entering
into the quotation
- . . . that they had taken up the issue of "coercive persuasion
(brainwashing . . . .
|
|
24
|
- Further note that the author commented on the material in the conclusion
of the paragraph.
- The methods seem to be strikingly like brainwashing.
|
|
25
|
- identify the source [sometimes, not always, though you always document
it, thus identifying it.]
- summarize to provide context
- paraphrase to adjust syntax
- directly quote to lend authority or precision
- comment to assure coherence
|
|
26
|
- Remember that your ideas are primary and that you are only using
quotations to add support to your points. Therefore, they must always be
integrated into your writing.
|
|
27
|
- If using a phrase to introduce, punctuate with a comma:
,
- As the United States Catholic Bishops Conference asserts,
"Catholics in the United States have special responsibilities to
protect human life and dignity and to stand with those who are poor and
vulnerable" (Everyday, par. 16).
|
|
28
|
- If using a whole sentence as an introduction, end it with a colon:
:
- But the Bishops deny that political opinions are simply a private
matter: "Our political choices should not reflect simply our own
interests, partisan preferences or ideological agendas, but should be
shaped by the principles of our faith and our commitment to justice,
especially to the weak and vulnerable" (USCC, Everyday, par. 16). [The
quotation “proves” the first sentence.]
|
|
29
|
- Finally, it is possible just to blend your sentence right into the
quotation with no punctuation:
-
The US Catholic Conference repudiates the contention "that
religion is a private matter, to be tolerated as long as it is detached
from our lives as workers and citizens" (Everyday, par. 19).
|
|
30
|
- English has a wealth of alternatives to "said" or
"stated" for introducing quotations. Choosing from among these
alternatives allows the sophisticated writer to characterize--and to
interpret--the content, context, and attitude of quotations.
|
|
31
|
- Remember: Your readers are interested in your opinions, insights, and
analysis.
- In most cases, if they want a
full understanding of the background literature associated with your
topic, they'll go back to the original.
- Use outside material to further illustrate your argument or
analysis--according to the Little Brown Handbook, the point of research
is to investigate and go beyond sources, to interpret them and convey
your interpretations to your readers (556).
The Writing Center
Dr. Janet Wright Starner, Director
|
|
32
|
- acknowledges
adds
admits
agrees
argues
asserts
believes
claims
comments
compares
confirms
- contends
declares
denies
disputes
emphasizes
|
|
33
|
- The words in the following list are not interchangeable: each will put a
quotation in a slightly different light. The list is not exhaustive.
- Acknowledged, added, admitted, advised, advocated, affirmed, agreed,
alleged, announced, answered, argued, articulated, asked, assented,
asserted, assured, attested.
Begged, boasted, Called, charged, claimed, commanded, commented,
conceded, concluded, concurred, confessed, contended, continued,
contradicted, counseled, countered, debated, decided, declared,
demanded, denied, denounced, described, dictated, directed, disclosed,
elaborated, enjoined, entreated, exclaimed, exhorted, explained.
Granted, Held, hesitated, hinted, Imparted, indicated, inferred,
inquired, insinuated, insisted, intimated, Lamented, lectured, lied,
Maintained, mentioned, noted, objected, observed, ordered, pleaded,
pointed out, preached, proclaimed, pronounced, protested, proved,
queried, questioned, quibbled, quoted, reasoned, recited, recognized,
recounted, refuted, regretted, reiterated, rejoined, related, remarked,
reminded, repeated, replied, reported, requested, responded, revealed,
ruled, stated, stipulated, suggested, supposed.
Talked, testified, thought, told, translated, urged, uttered,
vowed, warned.
|
|
34
|
- first, second etc.
- next, last, finally
- first of all
- meanwhile
- followed by, after that
- next, before, after
|
|
35
|
- for example
- for instance
- this can be seen
- when/where . . .
- such is the case in . . .
|
|
36
|
- in a different way/sense
- similarly
- likewise
- similar to
- like, just like
- conversely
|
|
37
|
- in addition
- also, another
- besides, too
- one can also say
- furthermore
- moreover
|
|
38
|
- in contrast
- however
- on the other hand
- but
- on the contrary
- a different view is . . .
- differing from
- unlike
|
|
39
|
- however
- on the other hand
- instead
- in contrast
- whereas
- nevertheless
- despite
- even though
- but one could also say . . .
|
|
40
|
- first, second, third etc.
- next, last, finally
|
|
41
|
- next, last, finally
- more importantly, less significantly
- more significantly, less significantly
- above all
- primarily
|
|
42
|
- Knowing when to quote and when not to quote is important for producing a
valuable paper. Quoting in excess will not impress your reader /teacher
/professor who wants to know what you have understood from the
information that you collected.
- Indirect quotation (paraphrasing and summarizing) reflects that you have
thought about the information and are using it to present your point of
view of the topic being researched.
- References (citations, documentation) are made to support your ideas so
that the facts can be verified by the reader. The best advice is to
paraphrase and summarize whenever possible.
|
|
43
|
- When direct quotation is necessary, kept it as short as possible. Long
quotations may be distracting to readers and may contain material
irrelevant to the central focus of your paper.
- So, keep your direct quotations short and to the point.
|
|
44
|
- 1. Because the author's words are so impressive that to put them into
your own words would lessen their impact.
- 2. Because the author's words are so precise that to express them in any
other words would change their meaning.
- 3. Because the author's words are so concise--I would have to use twice
as many words to paraphrase the passage.
|
|
45
|
- When you use a quotation, you must incorporate it into your own message.
- Further, you must do that in such a way that your paper has a smooth,
natural rhythm. Otherwise, your readers will not see the connection
between the quotation and the rest of the message in your paper.
- In other words, the quotation will appear to have no function.
|
|
46
|
- Insert ellipses ( . . . ) in places where you delete any words from the
original quotation. Note: . space . space . space
- Use brackets [ ] to add words
to or to substitute words for those in the original quotation.
|
|
47
|
- If you need to add words to or change words in a quotation, put the
additional or changed word within brackets [ ]. Two reasons for inserting words
are to
- Add words to help clarify a quotation.
- Substitute words to make a quotation fit smoothly into your own
sentence, as long as you don't change the author's intended meaning. For
example, use brackets to change verb tenses or to change pronouns to
nouns.
|
|
48
|
- Utterson tries to believe that all will be well with Dr. Jekyll, but
“Struggle as he might, there [is] borne in upon his mind a crushing
anticipation of calamity.”
- The novel has the word was instead of is. The tense would not fit the
sentence, so brackets [ ] are used to make the quotation fit your own
sentence and usage.
|
|
49
|
- What you say after you have included a quotation depends on your
purpose. The important point to remember is that your readers will not
understand why a quotation is included unless you tell them.
|
|
50
|
- Add details, facts, or ideas that reveal the quotation's truth.
- Explain the connection between the quotation and what has already been
presented in your paper.
- Refer to an important word or phrase in the quotation and explain its
significance.
- Explain how your position matches the quotation: for example, agree or
disagree with the point made in the quotation.
|
|
51
|
- Example:
- As Markel says, "To enter into a culture is to be able to hear, in
Lionel Trilling's phrase,
its special 'hum and buzz of implication.’ " These
“hummings” and buzzings” bring in nonverbal areas and the prime
stumbling block. People from different cultures inhabit different
nonverbal sensory words. Each sees, hears, feels, and smells only that
which has some meaning or importance for him.
|
|
52
|
- The work you produce for senior project may involve the important ideas,
writings, and discoveries of experts in your field of study.
- These contributions are always acknowledged by referencing, and there
will be times when you introduce other people's views into your work and
want to name them in the text.
- Naming other authors when you're introducing their views into your work
can be done with quotations or paraphrase.
|
|
53
|
- Realize that you will often not use the author’s name in your own
sentences. You only identify him in your words [as opposed to your
parenthetical documentation] when he is important, when the reader will
or should know who he is.
|
|
54
|
- Example: James Allen Smith has said that yoga is one of the two most
important leisure activities America has ever seen in terms of mental
health for its participants.
- Who is James Allen Smith?
- Why should anyone believe him?
- Why should anyone care what in the world he has said?
|
|
55
|
- when you want to use an author as an authoritative voice
- to introduce an author's position you may wish to discuss
- to provide evidence for your own writing
- to make a clear distinction between the views of different authors
- to make a clear distinction between an author's views and your own
|
|
56
|
- X states that . . .
- X claims that . . .
- X asserts that . . .
- X agrees that . . .
- X strongly argues . . .
- X comments that . . .
- X suggests that . . .
- X comments that . . .
- X says that . . .
|
|
57
|
- Example
- Harrison (567) strongly argues that "Freud suffered from a serious
personality disorder.”
|
|
58
|
- Any sentence that contains a quotation must be grammatically
correct. The quotation itself may contain a mistake [sic.], but
the grammar of the quotation must match the grammar of your own
sentence.
- Ask about [sic.].
|
|
59
|
- wrong
In some Indian societies, control over agriculture and certain
political powers such as nominating "the male candidates for chief,
and initiate a chief's removal" were given to women.
- better
In some Indian societies, control over agriculture and certain
political powers such as nominating "the male candidates for
chief" and initiating "a chief's removal" were given to
women.
|
|
60
|
- OR
- In some Indian societies, control over agriculture and certain political
powers such as nominating "the male candidates for chief, and
[initiating] a chief's removal" were given to women.
|
|
61
|
- weak
One last quote from Jones to reinforce his statement is, “The
whole purpose of colonization was to get rich quick, which explains the
English's treatment of the Indians."
- better
Summarizing his entire argument, Jones maintains that “The whole
purpose of colonization was to get rich quick, which explains the
English's treatment of the Indians."
|
|
62
|
- wrong
Europeans felt that Indian family life raised "the specter
of promiscuous women...lack of chastity and modesty."
- better
Europeans felt that Indian family life raised "the specter
of promiscuous women." They were particularly concerned about
the "lack of chastity and modesty."
|
|
63
|
- You can also, rarely, add information to a quotation by enclosing your
own words in square brackets [ ].
- There are several reasons you may wish to do this:
- To clarify an unclear pronoun reference
- To keep your tenses consistent
- To add needed explanatory material [used very rarely!]
- To point out a grammatical error in the original source by placing [sic.]
after the error. Note: Unless you identify errors in quotations with [sic],
I will assume that any mistakes are your typos and will point them out.
|
|
64
|
|